Settle It · Famous debates

Thermostat: 68 or 72?

Ruled September 2026 · 2 min read · How Settle It works

One of you is cold. One of you is paying. The Department of Energy's winter recommendation, a fair compromise, and who buys the blanket. Below: both sides as they'd actually put it, then the ruling The Judge gives when two people bring this one into a Settle It room.

Both sides

S
Sam

68 is a normal indoor temperature. Every degree you turn it up costs real money. Put on a sweater like an adult.

R
Riley

72. I refuse to live in a walk-in refrigerator to save eleven dollars a month. A home should not require outerwear.

The Judge's ruling

Verdict
Neither. 70 by day, 67 overnight.

Ruling: The Department of Energy's winter guidance is 68°F while you're home and awake, lower while asleep or away, and it estimates roughly 1% savings per degree per 8 hours. So Sam has the government on his side. But Sam is arguing about money and Riley is arguing about comfort, and those are different cases. 70 during the day gives Riley two of her four degrees, 67 overnight gives Sam his savings where nobody feels them, and a programmable thermostat means neither of you touches the dial.

Sentence: Sam buys Riley a very good blanket. Riley stops adjusting the thermostat after 10 p.m. The schedule goes in the thermostat, not in the group chat.

Verdict card: Thermostat: 68 or 72? — Neither. 70 by day, 67 overnight.

Share the card, or better, send the loser the link. Sample ruling: in a real room The Judge asks each side follow-up questions first, then rules on what you actually said.

Settle yours → Free. Two people, one thread, one verdict.

Sources

More famous debates

← Settle It